Analyzing Spread Between Tether Prices Across Centralized Exchanges

Tether (USDT) has become one of the most widely used stablecoins in the cryptocurrency market. As a stablecoin, Tether aims to maintain a value pegged to $1 USD. However, there can often be differences in USDT prices across various centralized cryptocurrency exchanges. Analyzing the spread between Tether prices on centralized exchanges provides insights into market dynamics, arbitrage opportunities, and risks.

Why Can Tether Prices Vary Across Exchanges?

Several factors can lead to spreads between Tether prices on different centralized exchanges:

  • Liquidity - Exchanges with more Tether trading volume and liquidity tend to have tighter spreads. Exchanges with low liquidity can have larger spreads.
  • Demand/Supply Imbalances - If buyers on one exchange heavily outweigh sellers, the Tether price may trade at a premium. The opposite imbalance can lead to a discounted price.
  • Withdrawal/Deposit Frictions - Withdrawal and deposit limits, fees, and processing times across exchanges can prevent efficient arbitrage to close spreads quickly.
  • Counterparty Risks - Centralized exchanges carry counterparty risks that can affect Tether valuations. Perceived risks of insolvency or illiquidity can cause discounts.
  • Regulations - Restrictions on cross-border flows between jurisdictions can fragment liquidity and widen spreads.

Tracking and Comparing Tether Prices

Several steps are required to track and compare Tether prices across major centralized exchanges:

  • Identify the top Tether exchanges by volume and liquidity. Useful to monitor the top 5-10 exchanges.
  • Collect pricing data across exchanges using the Tether/USD pair. Need granular historical data.
  • Calculate percentage spreads relative to the average price across exchanges.
  • Chart and visualize spreads over time to identify trends and outliers.
  • Compute rolling averages of spreads to smooth out short-term fluctuations.
  • Compare against historical averages to detect abnormal pricing gaps. Widenings may signal risks.

Traders also need reliable market data feeds to monitor real-time prices and spreads. Watching order book depth is also useful for gauging liquidity.

Arbitrage Strategies Between Tether Exchanges

Analyzing Tether price differences allows traders to profit from arbitrage strategies:

  • Buy on discounted exchange and sell on premium exchange. This is the most basic arbitrage trade when spreads widen enough to cover fees and remain profitable.
  • Cross-exchange futures trades. Traders can set up long/short futures positions on exchanges with diverging prices rather than transferring Tether between platforms.
  • Triangular arbitrage across three pairs. Traders can exploit pricing inefficiencies across three or more currency pairs between exchanges.
  • Between spot and futures pricing. Spreads between spot Tether and Tether futures prices can also offer arbitrage opportunities.

To successfully capitalize on cross-exchange Tether arbitrage, traders need sufficient capital, low-latency connectivity, and no withdrawal restrictions between platforms. Persistent opportunities tend to be rapidly competed away among institutional traders.

Risks of Divergent Tether Prices

Some key risks arise from divergent Tether prices across centralized exchanges:

  • Reduced fungibility. The "moneyness" and purchasing power of Tether is no longer uniform across the market. This conflicts with Tether's goals as a uniform stablecoin.
  • Market fragmentation. Wide, persistent spreads across Tether exchanges could lead to fragmented liquidity and reduced pricing efficiency. This harms market quality over time.
  • Loss of credibility. If spreads routinely sustain more than 1-2%, it may signal issues with Tether's peg stability and undermine trust in its 1:1 USD backing.
  • Manipulation opportunities. Volatile spreads widen the potential for manipulated valuations, wash trading, and other abuses by exchanges or Tether issuers.

Monitoring stablecoin spreads provides vital intelligence on market stability and risks. Analyzing cross-exchange Tether pricing should be part of every active trader and market analyst's toolkit.

What Factors Contribute Most to Tether Spread Volatility?

The volatility and size of spreads between Tether prices on centralized exchanges depends on several influential factors:

  • Liquidity differences - Exchanges with more Tether trading volume exhibit lower volatility in spreads due to higher liquidity. Thin liquidity magnifies volatility.
  • Withdrawal/deposit restrictions - Limits on moving Tether between exchanges reduce arbitrage flows and allow more volatile spreads. Loose restrictions tighten spreads.
  • Wide bid/ask spreads - Exchanges with wider average bid-ask spread tend to have higher spread volatility between exchanges. Tighter bid-ask spreads dampen volatility.
  • Changes in counterparty risk - Shifts in market confidence regarding exchange solvency or Tether backing lead to higher volatility in cross-exchange pricing.
  • Jurisdictional frictions - Regulatory restrictions on flows between regions hinder arbitrage and allow spreads to fluctuate more widely.

In summary, limited arbitrage possibilities due to liquidity, transaction costs, and legal risks appear to be the dominant drivers of unstable Tether spreads across centralized exchanges.

How Could Tether Better Maintain Its Peg Across Exchanges?

Tether faces challenges maintaining a tight peg across different exchanges due to market fragmentation and liquidity differences. Here are some steps that could help Tether stabilize and tighten its peg:

  • Increase Tether redemptions - Expand the ability for traders and exchanges to redeem USDT directly with Tether for fiat USD to better balance supply.
  • Adjust Tether issuance - Strategically issue new USDT on exchanges where the Tether price trades at a premium to bring the peg closer to $1.
  • Collateral transparency - Provide trusted third-party attestations on Tether's reserves to reassure markets of sufficient backing and reduce risk premiums.
  • Whitelisted transfers - Streamline withdrawal review and transfer times between trusted exchange partners to enable faster arbitrage.
  • Exchange partnerships - Explore incentives, liquidity deals, and integrations with exchanges to tighten Tether spreads in their pools.
  • Limit orders - Explore issuing limit orders with collateral to automatically buy below and sell above $1 peg when spreads widen too far on any exchange.

By leveraging these strategies, Tether may reduce fragmentation and volatility between its prices on centralized exchanges. However, fundamental market structure differences will likely persist in causing some pricing divergences.

As the author of this article, I wanted to share a candid perspective. Analyzing stablecoin spreads has been an obsession of mine recently as the volatility keeps me up at night. This megatrend feels so powerful that I worry we are witnessing a paradigm shift. But it's been difficult to get others to share my sense of concern and urgency. My hope is that pieces like this can help sound the alarm before it's too late. We owe it to ourselves and future generations to get this right.

  • Tether issuance is centralized by the Tether company, allowing them to mint new USDT at will.
  • This has led to questions about whether Tether is truly backed 1:1 by USD reserves as claimed.
  • However, if Tether issuance was decentralized and distributed, with issuance governed by smart contracts, it could enhance transparency and collateralization.
  • For example, a decentralized model could potentially require overcollateralization, community oversight of reserves, and scheduled financial audits encoded on-chain.
  • In theory, decentralizing Tether issuance could reduce reliance on any single entity and boost confidence in its peg and reserves.
  • But major technical and coordination hurdles would need to be solved to transition from the current centralized structure.

Read more