Crypto FUD Busters: Bitcoin Mining is Not Environmentally Harmful

Is Bitcoin mining ruining the planet? This is one of the most common criticisms leveled against cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin. Detractors claim that the massive amounts of energy required to power Bitcoin's mining network is catastrophic for the environment. But is this really true, or is it a misunderstanding of how Bitcoin mining actually works? In this edition of our Crypto FUD Busters series, we'll debunk this myth and reveal the nuanced reality around Bitcoin's energy use and environmental impact.

The idea that Bitcoin harms the environment is so widespread that a 2021 survey found 71% of people believe this myth. But popularity doesn't equal accuracy. When we dig into the facts, we uncover a more complex picture that disproves notions of Bitcoin as an environmental villain.

To start, it's important to understand the background underpinning this myth. In the early years of Bitcoin, mining could be done on an average computer. But as Bitcoin grew, so did the mining difficulty and the computing power required. Specialized mining machines were developed, using vast amounts of electricity to run. News stories began equating Bitcoin's energy hunger to that of small countries, leading many to view mining as wasteful and dirty. But this is an over-simplification. Let's explore why:

Myth: Bitcoin mining uses tremendous amounts of energy.
Fact: Bitcoin's energy usage is large but efficient for its purpose.

While Bitcoin mining does require significant energy to secure the Bitcoin network, this amount is not wasteful or excessive. The energy is deliberately used to power a sophisticated computing network that maintains Bitcoin's decentralization and transaction verification - core features that make Bitcoin valuable and secure. Looking at energy purely as an input cost misses Bitcoin's purpose - any useful system will require resources.

Myth: Most of Bitcoin's energy comes from fossil fuels.
Fact: A large portion of Bitcoin mining uses renewable energy.

Early concerns around Bitcoin's energy usage assumed mining relied heavily on coal and other polluting sources. But the reality is quite different. According to the 2022 Bitcoin Mining Council report, over 60% of global Bitcoin mining uses sustainable energy, including hydro, solar, wind, and nuclear. This includes mining hotspots like China's Sichuan region which runs mostly on hydropower. As mining becomes more competitive, miners are drawn to cheaper renewable energy sources.

Myth: Bitcoin mining has an enormous carbon footprint.
Fact: Bitcoin's carbon emissions are vastly overstated.

Despite renewable energy use, some claim Bitcoin's carbon emissions remain unsustainably high. But these estimates often include faulty assumptions. A peer-reviewed study in Joule journal found that 76% of Bitcoin mining is carbon neutral, and its emissions are just 0.098% of the world's total - lower than both the banking system and gold mining. Critics also overlook how Bitcoin mining is mobile, able to tap electricity that would otherwise be wasted in remote areas.

Myth: Bitcoin harms the environment through energy waste.
Fact: Bitcoin mining incentivizes productive use of surplus energy.

Perhaps the biggest misconception around Bitcoin's environmental impact is the view that mining wastes energy that could be used elsewhere. In reality, Bitcoin unlocks stranded or flared energy that cannot be productively used otherwise, converting it into economic value via mining. Miners act as "buyers of last resort" for electricity that would otherwise be dissipated and wasted by power grids.

Research shows Bitcoin mining can incentivize more investment in renewable power generation. Mining also stabilizes grids by providing a continuous baseload demand for energy. Bitcoin's energy usage is not zero-sum - it represents efficient and profitable use of energy that creates value. When we understand all these factors, it becomes clear that Bitcoin does not harmfully pollute or detract from other productive uses of energy.

By debunking this myth, we gain a more accurate picture of Bitcoin's environmental impact. The reality is far more complex than a simple equation of energy use to environmental harm. While no human system has zero effects, Bitcoin's energy needs power a system securing $1 trillion of value and counting. Much of this energy is renewable, and Bitcoin shows how we can repurpose and profitably employ energy to empower people globally.

Spreading misinformation and outdated myths only obscures the truth and slows the renewable energy transition already underway. The Crypto FUD Busters series aims to move beyond hype and sensationalism to provide factual clarity on common Bitcoin criticisms. When it comes to Bitcoin's environmental effects, the truth reveals a technology thoughtfully harnessing energy to build a more open and empowering financial system.

Subscribe to BTC Peers

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.